My recommendations of mutuals funds (July -Sept 2018)
The mutual fund industry has gone through a GST kind of moment in the past six months, where SEBI has enforced rules for categorisation and rationalisation of MF schemes.
In October 2017, SEBI released a new set of rules for MF schemes and every AMC had to implement it by 30th of June. You can read the full circular here and here.
The circular clearly defined the large, mid and small cap universe – large cap stocks are defined as the top 100 stocks by market capitalisation; mid cap as the stocks from 101st till 250th by market capitalisation and the rest stocks (251st onwards) are classified as small caps.
SEBI also has categorised equity MF’s as multicap, large cap, large and mid cap, mid cap, small cap, dividend yield, value fund, contra fund, focussed fund, sectoral fund and ELSS.
Similarly SEBI has categorised debt schemes in 16 categories, hybrid funds in 6 categories, solution oriented schemes in 2 categories ( retirement and children’s fund) and other schemes as Index and Fund of funds.
SEBI has also mandated that each fund house can only have one mutual fund in each category.
Due to this, many MF schemes have been merged, renamed, reclassified in the past three months. The fund managers had to rebalance their portfolios based on this SEBI mandate.
Now that these changes have been implemented, the MF industry would slowly get back to normal business of trying to outperform their peers and attracting more investor money. I believe, the industry will take a few months to stabilise.
My MF selection methodology remains the same – it starts with defining the different investment objectives that you (my reader) may have and the category of funds that you will need to invest in.
Then I look at the size of the fund – the amount of total investor money the fund is managing (called Assets under management) – as per me, the bigger the fund size, the more likely it will have a better fund management team and better governance.
Then I look at the past history of performance. The past qtr rationalisation of funds means that it is difficult to look at the past history ( many funds have been merged and renamed) and so I will go more with the size of fund as of now.
So here are my current quarterly recommendations (July – Sept 2018):
If you are looking for growth in capital for long term (3 years or more investment timeframe):
Moderate risk and moderate return –Kotak standard multicap fund and SBI Blue Chip Fund and Aditya Birla Sun Life Frontline equity fund . All these funds manage large amount of investor money and have given 15% plus per annum compounded over the past five years. As long as the Indian economy and GDP is growing, these funds are expected to do well.
Slightly higher risk and higher return – HDFC Mid cap opportunities fund – this fund manages appx 17000 crore investor money and has given 25% per annum compounded over five years. This fund invests in stocks mid cap and small cap companies.
There are also some industry specific themes that would do well in 2018 -19. I believe that Rural theme and FMCG industries whould give good returns in 2018-19. The funds for these themes are Sundaram rural and consumption fund and SBI consumption opportunities fund.
Low risk and reasonable return – ICICI Prudential equity and debt fund – right now this category ( and this fund) is not performing ( as compared to a FD) as the equity markets have been not performing since Jan -but over a 3 year period, it should give you appx 10% – this fund has 65% -70% of it’s money invested in equity markets and remaining 30% in bonds.
Really low risk and OK with low returns – You can look at investing in ultra short term debt funds – the fund that I recommend is ICICI Prudential savings fund – this fund should give slightly above FD rates in the coming year (and this interest is taxed).
If you are looking to avail tax savings under Section 80C – then invest in Aditya Birla Sunlife Tax relief (96G) fund – As you are investing for section 80C tax savings, you need to stay invested for three years.
Tag:Mutual fund
21 Comments
Sir, just to understand better. I was checking in midcap category. More than HDFC midcap, Sundaram DSP black rock midcap and l&t midcap have given more reasons. Is there any specific reason for choosing HDFc midcap over others ? Pls suggest
Shyamala – I believe that MF selection should not be only based on returns – many a times focus on returns leads to short termism and that is not what we want. I believe that more than returns, the size of the fund also matters. The bigger the fund, the higher the chances of a better fund management team as they can afford better fund managers. Hence I have a bias towards AUM more than the past returns. More details are there in my book on how I select mutual funds.
Hi Raja sir,
I am great fan of your book, blog and advice. Learnt a lot from you. 🙂
One more thing – Bigger the AUM, difficult it is to manage for the firm (and fund manager) and they might stop fresh inflows into it. I noticed this in case of 2 funds – DSPBR Small Cap and Reliance Small Cap. I am not able to start fresh SIPs in the same.
Ron – Agreed that sometimes the fund manager may be forced to stop further intake as that may diilute the fund performance. But that is OK. It is a good problem to have once a while. It would be a matter pride for a fund manager to be in this position that there are people ready to give him/her money and he is refusing it. From the perspective of the investor, it is not the best of situations to be in to be refused by a fund manager – but once in a while I think it is OK – it does not happen very often.
Thank you so much for your explanation sir.
Hi Sir,
I half agree as sampling has to be for long years for selection but my experience in seeing mutual Funds whose AUM grows big they perform like Index Fund as more money flow they start buying many stocks and fund will not have concentrated portfolio
Agree with you Prabhu – as the fund grows bigger, it is difficult to perform – hence my filter has the AUM factor and then the performance factor – the funds that I am recommending have surely beaten the index over long term. If they have not out performed the index, then they would not be in my recommendation.
Hello Sir,
Thanks for sharing the mutual funds recommendation. I also feel that the age and the goal of the fund needs to be considered before selection.
Thanks Jay -I think everyone has their own ways of short listing MF’s and I have explained my way. This has worked for me. I respect your views and I do believe if it works for you – you should stay with it.
Any views on Franklin India bluechip fund – large cap. The fund has seen most of the cycles and given 20% CAGR since inception.
Ketan -Franklin India Blue chip fund is also a good fund and if you have invested in it – you must stay invested. The reason it is not in my recommeendations is because I also filter based on the Assets the fund manages -I only take the three largest funds in it’s category and Franklin India bluechip fund is not one of the three largest funds in the large cap category.
Thank you sir.
Hi Sir,
I have couple questions:
1. In your past MF recommendations (Apr – Jun ’18), you have mentioned Reliance tax saver is a good option for ELSS. Currently, the fund has been performing bad (also downgraded by many research sites such as moneycontrol and Value-research). So, Should i invest more (I did a lumpsum investment in April) or maintain status quo?
2. The Indigo shares have comedown and hovering below the recommended level of Rs 1180-1200 (from your post dated 6th May 2018). This is because of 2nd high profile exit in recent days. So, Do you think this is the right time to enter or should I wait for some more time as more exits are anticipated and the price may fall to much lower level
Praveen – ELSS funds are for three years – and we take a call based on parameters at a point of time – the parameters I take a call on are a combination of the current AUM and the returns for past 3 years ( as it is ELSS funds) – the larger the AUM, the better the fund management team is likely to be and the performance has to be also good if not the best ( as sometimes the fund manager may take higher risk to get better performance). Right now I also see that the Reliance tax saver fund has not done well – but I would give it time – in the past it was a good performing fund and we have invested for three years – so let us be patient. So do not be swayed by short term performance – and stay invested.
Should you add more – Not really. Just because you invested in the past should not sway your decision. Right now I think you should add to the ABSL Tax saver fund where the performance looks good (even though the AUM is smaller in comparison) – the reason I am recommending it is the stocks in the portfolio – the portfolio is a moving parameter and the fund manager may exit these stocks at his will- but it looks good to me and hence I am recommending it.
Indigo is a story that will build up over the next few qtrs when the financial performance reveals how well they have managed despite issues of Oil prices, senior exits and engine troubles -my thesis is that they will be able to manage these issues – so whatever happens to the stock between the quarterly results is pure market speculation and I would not go by it. I will give it three qtrs and judge for myself if they have been able to manage the situation well.
Hope my approach is making sense to you.
Sure Sir,
Thank you very much for your inputs and clarification about Reliance tax saver, i was thinking to add more but now kept it on hold. SIP in ABSL has been going on for past couple of months (based on my own research, felt happy that my analysis is correct when you suggested it).
Please continue posting your valuable suggestions and ideas
Hi Sir, do you have take on PPFAS long term fund? Your views as it invested in USA markets also .
PPFAS as an AMC is a good AMC – their Long term equity fund is a good fund – even though it is a small fund in terms of AUM. It has a few US equity exposure as well – that Icannot comment ass it is the fund manager’s choice (and my knowledge of US markets is incomplete) – but overall it is a good fund.
HI Raja Sir , Thanks for your details , i have invested in SIP on Franklin Build India,Franklin Inidia Blue chip,Aditya Birla Sunlife from past 3 years .So far its not in good Returns , may i know your view on it ?, i am looking for 10 years investment is it a right option to do SIP on these funds ? please advice .
Vinu – The Sensex gave negative returns in 2015 and gave positive returns in 2016 and 2017 and in 2018 – it has been struggling – hence your funds may have not shown must growth over this period. I also have come to the conclusion that the Tnfra story looks good on paper – but the funds do not do well as this industry has lots of business issues and governmental linkages and hence it is best to stay away. Hence the Franklin Build India fund is not something that I would recommend. The Franklin India Bluechip fund is a large cap fund – in large cap I wuld recommend other funds not this – the ABSL frontline equity is preffered – the list is in my post. The third fund that you have asked me is not fully mentioned – you have mentioned Aditya Birla Sunlife – but that is the AMC name – which fund of this AMC are you talking about?
Hello Sir
Isn’t ABSL EQUITY FUND A BETTER OPTION THAN ABSL FRONTLINE EQUITY AS MENTIONED IN YOUR POST AS IT GIVES FUND MANAGER MORE FLEXIBILITY BEING A MULTICAP
Brian – you have a point – with the reclassification of the mutual funds, the multicap funds will behave more like the “old” large cap funds – I am in the process of revisiting the recommendations – wait for a week or so for my next post on this topic.
Thanks for this message.